inflow-logo

Inflow: eCommerce Marketing Agency

  • Services
    • SEO
    • PPC
    • CRO
    • Paid Social
  • Clients
    • Case Studies
  • About Us
    • Contact Us
  • Insights Blog
  • Request Proposal
  • Services
    • SEO
    • PPC
    • CRO
    • Paid Social
  • Clients
    • Case Studies
  • About Us
    • Contact Us
  • Insights Blog
  • Request Proposal

Home > eCommerce Digital Marketing Blog > Conversion Rate Optimization > The Axe vs Scalpel: Should You Redesign or Optimize Your eCommerce Website?

The Axe vs Scalpel: Should You Redesign or Optimize Your eCommerce Website?

Posted By Michael Kuehn on March 8, 2016

  • 8shares

eCommerce conversions site improvements

Axe vs. Scalpel – Full Site Redesign or Continuous Optimization

In a previous post, we discussed why during a site redesign you should engage your UX experts, whether internal or external, prior to working with designers. But should you even be conducting a redesign? This is a massive undertaking for any site, so you want to be sure it is worth the opportunity cost and the expense of any third parties you bring in to assist. There may be safer and less expensive ways to overhaul your site without doing a full-scale redesign. So before you start planning your project, you need to answer the big question:

Why do you want a redesign?

  • Are you just trying to update the look and feel? If so, why?
  • Do you need to update to newer technology, such as responsive design?
  • Are you restructuring the site to engage existing users in a totally different way? Or are you trying to fix a specific problem(s) current users are having?
  • Are you trying to address a new customer base? If so, how do they need to be treated differently from the current customers?

Person thinking about whether or not they should redesign their website.

While any of these could be a good reason to redesign your site, you also need to consider your entrenched users:

  • Are there important workflows that need to be preserved? If changed, what are the education requirements?
  • If you expect to lose existing users due to these changes, are the new opportunities able to compensate?

A simple search of “common reasons for a site redesign” turns up pages of “Top X” lists of items like the above. The point is, you need to know the top goals for your website and how successful you currently are at meeting them. Once you’ve identified those goals, we can look at the main question a different way: “Are my goals only accomplished by a complete overhaul, or can the goals be accomplished by tackling the problems in smaller chunks?”

For some items, such as changing over to responsive design from a site that is not mobile-friendly, you will have to rework most of the site, which makes it an ideal time to consider this larger project – the axe.

On the other hand, if you’re able to identify specific pain points on your site, incremental change (i.e The Scalpel) can be a much better tool.

All cases are different, so it’s important to consider all the factors. The questions above should provide a good starting point, but there may be others specific to your business that only you can identify. When it comes down to it, most websites have clearly identifiable problems that can be fixed with incremental change. While it may seem like the slower approach – it takes longer for the entire site to be updated incrementally vs. all at once – often Continuous Optimization ends up being a safer investment that offers a larger return.

Site redesigns can take months to complete with no guarantee that the new version will outperform the old — pity the marketer who finds out after months of work that the shiny new site ended up losing to the original one. Moreover, if you make all the changes at once, you won’t know which changes were positive and which ones hurt.

A Continuous Optimization program that validates results through testing, on the other hand, can bring you incremental improvements in a much shorter time period without the expense or opportunity cost of an overhaul.

As you are working on the next optimization, you also reap the benefits of earlier optimizations, which compounds these improvements. With limited development resources, this has the added benefit of not tying up your entire team on one large project.

Ultimately, there will be cases where the axe is the right tool for the job. But if you can clearly identify the source of your site’s problems, the scalpel can address the pain — without the collateral damage and expense.

  • 8shares

0 Comments on "The Axe vs Scalpel: Should You Redesign or Optimize Your eCommerce Website?"

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Related Posts

  • Case Study: How Pruning This Online Store’s Blog Boosted Strategic Content Revenue by 64% For the subject of this case study, one of our clients benefited with a 64% increase in strategic content revenue after we helped to prune their blog content. Read on to learn more!
  • 10 Best eCommerce Marketing Automation Systems Compared We compare Klaviyo, ActiveCampaign, Hubspot, and more in this evaluation of eCommerce marketing automation systems. Which system is right for you?
  • How eCommerce Blogging Has Assisted in $40K+ in Sales This Year for a Retail Site eCommerce blogging has assisted in over $40,000 worth in sales this year for one of our clients. That means visitors are reading at least one blog post before making a purchase.
Michael Kuehn on couch with dog.

Michael Kuehn

With more than five years of digital marketing experience, Michael Kuehn combines analytics-based decision-making with a passion for user experience. In addition to CRO, Kuehn is experienced in both project and product management, having previously managed five software units for a leading loyalty website.

View Author’s Profile

Related Categories

  • A/B Testing (11)
  • eCommerce Page CRO (10)
  • Mobile Conversion Optimization (5)
  • Tools and Plugins (14)
  • Usability (5)
  • Most Popular Posts:

    eCommerce Marketing Automations Systems Compared
    Technical Mobile Best Practices for SEO and Usability
    Expanding the Horizons of eCommerce Content Strategy
    Thin & Duplicate Content: eCommerce SEO
    5 Ways eCommerce Content Audits Can Increase Revenue
    Want to get content like this straight to your inbox? Subscribe to our weekly content alerts and monthly Inflow Insights newsletter now.

    Categories

    • SEO
      • Content Marketing
      • Link Building
      • On-Page SEO
      • SEO Strategy
      • Technical SEO
    • Paid Advertising
      • Goal Metrics and Analytics
      • Paid Search
      • Paid Search Shopping
      • Paid Social
    • Conversion Rate Optimization
      • A/B Testing
      • eCommerce Page CRO
      • Mobile Conversion Optimization
      • Tools and Plugins
      • Usability
    • Case Studies
    • eCommerce Strategy
      • KPIs and Reporting
    • Digital Marketing Trends in eCommerce
    • Inflow News

    Request a Proposal

    We'll build a custom proposal to meet your goals. Get the process started now.

    Google Premier PartnerInflow is a facebook-certified-creative-strategy-professional Moz Recommended Company Inc 5000 Inflow Clutch Profile
    • Services
      • SEO
      • PPC
      • Conversion
    • Case Studies
      • SEO
      • PPC
      • Conversion
    • Insights Blog
    • Resources
    • More
      • Contact
      • Careers
      • Press Info
      • Privacy Policy
    REQUEST A PROPOSAL
     
    CALL US AT 303-905-1504
    Monday - Friday, 8 a.m. - 6 p.m. (MST)
     
    facebook twitter linked-in linked-in rss

    Send this to a friend